Effect of Meat or Plant-based Alternatives on Muscle Protein Synthesis
A study comparing the effect of consuming ground beef, ground pork, tofu, or Beyond Meat burgers on muscle protein synthesis
The purpose of the study is to quantify and compare the serum amino acid profile, and muscle protein synthesis rates, in response to consuming isonitrogenous amounts of ground meat (beef and pork) or plant-based alternatives -(soy and pea protein-based patties). Specific aim 1: Describe the post-prandial amino acid profile in serum in the 3 hours following consumption of the following four burger patties, in quantities calculated to deliver 20 grams of protein: ground beef, ground pork, Beyond Meat® burger, and tofu burger. Specific aim 2: Compare the ability of these four different foods to activate mTORC1 and protein synthesis in muscle.
Amino Acid Profile and Muscle Protein Synthetic Response to Consuming Meat or Plant-based Alternatives
Study design: The first visit will be a brief meeting conducted over Zoom with one of the investigators (Karine Schaal), who will go over the study details with the volunteer, answer their questions, and obtain informed consent. Subjects will sign the informed consent electronically, using DocuSign. Subjects will be given a copy of their signed informed consent form. A paper copy of the consent form will be kept in a locked file cabinet in the office of the principal investigator. Study volunteers will come to the CTSC Clinical Research Center (CCRC) on four separate occasions. The CCRC is located in the Cypress Building adjacent to the UC Davis Medical Center (2221 Stockton Blvd, Suite D, Sacramento CA 95817). The four study visits will be test visits scheduled over a two week period (i.e. twice per week for 2 weeks), at the same time in the morning following and overnight (> 12 hour) fast. They will be asked to refrain from vigorous exercise, caffeine, nicotine and alcohol for 24 hours prior to each visit. Female volunteers will be asked to schedule their study visits within the first two weeks of their menstrual cycle (starting on the first day of menstrual bleeding), in order to control for ovarian hormone fluctuations which may impact digestion and metabolism. Upon arrival to the CCRC on the first test visit, each volunteer's height and weight will be measured. I. Baseline blood draw. Subjects will then be placed in individual testing rooms, equipped with a reclining phlebotomy armchair. A registered nurse or nurse practitioner will insert a 22G catheter in a forearm vein and an initial 3.5 mL baseline blood sample will be collected. II. Test meal. After the baseline blood sample is collected, subjects will consume one of the following four burgers in isonitrogenous amounts to deliver 20 g of protein: - 106g ground beef patty (85% lean + 15% fat) - 118g ground pork (72.5% lean + 27.5% fat) - 113g Beyond Meat® patty - 113g tofu patty Each food will be weighed before cooking. The beef, pork and Beyond® burgers will be grilled on an indoor electric grill until internal temperature reaches 165°F to comply with the USDA Recommendations for Food Safety (beef and pork, minimum 160°F) and manufacturer instructions (Beyond Meat®). Tofu burgers are pre-cooked and will be warmed by grilling for 2 minutes, per manufacturer recommendations. The internal temperature of the burgers will be monitored using a meat thermometer. The burgers will be served to the volunteers as soon as they are finished cooking. Subjects will be asked to consume each patty without buns or condiments within a 10 minute period, and instructed to chew thoroughly. They will also be asked to drink a 6 ounce glass of water with the meal. III. Postprandial blood draws. Following consumption of the test meal, the participants will remain at the research site, in their individual testing room, for another 3 hours, sitting quietly - they may bring books or electronic devices to pass the time. Five more blood samples of 3.5 mL each will be obtained at 30, 60, 90, 120 and 180 minutes after the test meal, totaling six blood draws of 3.5mL per visit (21mL per visit), and 84 mL of blood drawn in total for each subject completing the entire study. Blood will be collected in 3.5 mL serum separating tubes. Approximately 50 microliters of whole-blood will be used to measure blood glucose within 5 minutes of the draw. The rest will be allowed to clot for 1hr before centrifugation at 1000 x g for 10 minutes.The serum will be frozen and kept at -80°C until processed. 100 microliters of each serum sample will be used for determining amino acid concentrations by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) at the UC Davis Proteomics Core. Another 100 microliters will be used to measure insulin concentrations via enzyme-linked immunoassay. The rest of the serum will be used for developing the mTORC1 bioassay. The order in which subjects receive each test meal will be randomized to avoid any order effect, and at least a two-day washout period will be given between visits.
Healthy Meat protein Plant protein Muscle protein synthesis Ground beef Ground pork Tofu Beyond Meat Consumption of ground beef Consumption of ground pork Consumption of tofu burger Consumption of Beyond Meat burger
You can join if…
Open to people ages 18-30
- Healthy active male (n=8) and female (n=8) volunteers aged 18 - 30 years
- normal weight (BMI between 18 and 25 kg/m2) will be recruited to participate in the study.
- To be considered active, volunteers must meet the following American College of Sports
Medicine's guideline for physical activity for healthy adults: performing at least 150 minutes per week of moderate-to-vigorous intensity physical activity.
You CAN'T join if...
- Health or dietary restriction that would be affected by the foods consumed.
- Known food allergy to legumes (soybeans, peas, peanuts) or meat (beef or pork)
- Anemia (low red blood cell count)
- Overweight or obesity (BMI > 25 kg/m2)
- Currently not meeting the ACSM physical activity recommendations (IPAQ score < 150 min/week of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity)
- Metabolic or endocrine disorder that would affect the digestion, absorption, and/or physiological response to any of the nutrients ingested
- Receiving any medication that may interfere with the study
- Adults unable to consent
- Individuals who are not yet adults (infants, children, teenagers)
- Pregnant women
- CTSC Clinical Research Center
accepting new patients
Sacramento California 95817 United States
Lead Scientist at University of California Health
- Keith Baar (ucdavis)