Engaging Mental Effort: Process- and Person-Based Reward Experiences, Effort Reinforcement Intervention, and Cascading Effects on Challenging Tasks
a study on Performance vs. Effort Rewards
Summary
- Eligibility
- for people ages 9-13 (full criteria)
- Healthy Volunteers
- healthy people welcome
- Location
- at UC Davis
- Dates
- study startedstudy ends around
Description
Summary
Brief Summary: The goal of this clinical trial is to investigate the influences of children's prior experiences with rewards following successes at school and interventions aimed at influencing children's preferences for challenging cognitive tasks.
The main questions this study aims to answer are as follows:
- Does the frequency of process-based rewards (e.g., rewards for working hard) vs. outcomes-based rewards (i.e., rewards for a good grade) predict children's preferences for challenging cognitive tasks?
- Does providing rewards for taking on effortful cognitive tasks increase children's preferences for challenging cognitive tasks more than providing rewards for performing well on cognitive tasks?
- Does receiving rewards for taking on effortful cognitive tasks increase children's challenge-seeking in novel tasks and questionnaires relevant for academic achievement that have not been previously linked with rewards?
Participants will complete the following tasks:
- A matrix completion problem solving task, with options to seek tips for solving problems and options to quit early.
- A response inhibition task, with options to complete a harder or easier version of the task.
- A cognitive flexibility task, with options to complete a harder or easier version of the task.
- A puzzle completion task, with an option to quit early.
- Answer a set of questions about academic effort
- Parents will complete a set of questions about how they responded to children's recent successes and failures at school.
Details
In Session 1, 9.00 - 13.00-year-olds will complete the Persistence, Effort, Resilience, and Challenge-seeking task with matrix completion problems. Then, participants will be randomly assigned to one of two groups: A group rewarded for selecting a more challenging cognitive task over an easier cognitive task or a group rewarded for performing well regardless of which cognitive task they select to play. Participants will then complete the response inhibition task, with easier or harder options, and the task switching task, with easier or harder options, prior to receiving rewards, while receiving rewards (response inhibition only), and after receiving rewards. Then, participants will answer questions about their task preferences and questions about their academic effort. Parents will complete questionnaires about how they responded to children's recent successes and failures at school and about their efforts in helping children succeed in school.
In Session 2, approximately one week later, participants will complete the response inhibition tasks while receiving rewards according to their respective group assignments. Then, participants will complete the response inhibition task and task-switching task without rewards, an impossible puzzle task, and the Persistence, Effort, Resilience, and Challenge-seeking task. Lastly, participants will answer questions about their academic effort and general preferences for engaging in mental effort. Parents will complete questionnaires about how they responded to children's recent successes and failures at school.
Keywords
Performance vs. Effort Rewards, Mental Effort, Executive Function, Process-based praise, Performance Rewards, Effort Rewards
Eligibility
You can join if…
Open to people ages 9-13
- Children aged 9.00-13.00 years
You CAN'T join if...
- Known or diagnosed developmental disorder (autism, ADHD, other learning disorders or developmental delays)
Location
- Center for Mind and Brain
accepting new patients
Davis California 95616 United States
Details
- Status
- accepting new patients
- Start Date
- Completion Date
- (estimated)
- Sponsor
- University of California, Davis
- ID
- NCT07557732
- Study Type
- Interventional
- Participants
- Expecting 180 study participants
- Last Updated
Please contact me about this study
We will not share your information with anyone other than the team in charge of this study, which might include an external sponsor. Providing your contact details does not obligate you to participate in the research.
Thank you!
The study team should get back to you in a few business days.